The POLICEPAY Journal®

Thursday, August 17, 2006

www.policepayjournal.net  

Matt Barnard, Editor   matt@policepay.net    (405) 234-2235    

 

 

DOVER, DE

City, police seeking pact; officers without contract since end of June

OGDEN, UT

Ogden City Council to Reassess Police and Firefighter's Raise Deal

GARDEN CITY, MI

Garden City, police OK contract

ROCKFORD, IL

Rockford Police Could Ask Voters About Merger with County

                                             BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

City, police seeking pact; Dover officers without contract since end of June

From the Delaware State News, August 13, 2006

 

DOVER - A billboard on State Street near Silver Lake doesn't mince words: "Crime doesn't pay and neither does (Dover) City Council. Police contract expired 6-30-06."

 

The sign, erected by the Dover Fraternal Order of Police, conveys the message to the public that the city's 91 officers have been working without a contract for more than a month.

 

Eight unsuccessful meetings to negotiate a new three-year pact have given way to a series of mediation sessions that will begin later this month.

 

But asking both parties where things stand yields two different answers.

 

"I don't think we're in the same situation as last time," City Manager Anthony J.

 

DePrima said, referring to a 15-month process that stretched well past the June 2003 deadline into April 2004, when a settlement was reached.

 

"Both sides were close enough where we felt bringing a mediator in would be helpful. We got down to the root issues much quicker than the last time."

 

Mediation will begin Friday.

 

But Dover FOP president Sgt. Daniel McKeown said the lack of a contract hurts officer morale.

 

"We're constantly told we're the finest law enforcement agency in the state but when it comes to pay, we're not in the same range as other forces," Sgt. McKeown said.

"It's frustrating sometimes."

 

Officers, who are required to keep working due to a provision in the expired contract, will continue to protect and serve, Sgt. McKeown said.

 

Retired Dover police lieutenant Timothy Mullaney Sr., who is serving as the Dover FOP's legal counsel, said the city is not taking the negotiations seriously.

 

"The city didn't give us their first economic proposal until nine days before the contract expired," Mr. Mullaney said.

 

One of the major sticking points between the two sides is career development - adding a new rank of master corporal.

 

The new rank would create an additional pay grade, said Mr. DePrima, who would not disclose the city's position on the matter.

 

The FOP is pushing to add the rank - which would be higher than the current corporal rank - to prevent stagnation within the department.

 

"Currently, if you're a patrolman first class, the only way to get promoted to corporal is if someone retires or leaves," Sgt. McKeown said.

 

"Basically, you stall. It's not uncommon to stay there (at patrolman first class) for 10-12 years. We're the only larger police department in Delaware without a career development plan."

 

Under the FOP's proposal, a patrolman first class could test to become a corporal after six years - the same as the current program.

 

However, if no position is available, the patrolman automatically would be promoted to corporal after 10 years of service.

 

The promotion would carry a 4 percent raise.

 

Attaining the rank of master corporal would give the officer an additional 5 percent.

 

Currently, a promotion from patrolman first class to corporal carries a 9.8 percent raise.

 

Mr. Mullaney noted that the additional rank would require a step increase for the ranks of sergeant, lieutenant, captain and major, but he added that there are only a handful of officers in those positions.

 

Other issues remaining include health care and salary.

 

The city, Mr. Mullaney said, is offering 3 percent raises each year of the proposed three-year deal, while the FOP wants 4 percent for the second and third years.

 

Mr. Mullaney noted that several senior-level nonunion city workers have received double-digit raises over the past three years through a pay-for-performance system, while officers are asked to accept 9 percent over three years.

 

Although the contract talks continue, Council President Beverly C. Williams said she is confident the city and police can reach an accord much more quickly than the last go-round.

 

"Any time you get into long-term contract talks, it takes time to work things out," Mrs. Williams said.

 

"(Last time), we ended up with a contract the city could live with and support financially and one that benefited the officers as well."

 

 

Ogden City Council to Reassess Police and Firefighter's Raise Deal

From KSLTV, August 15th, 2006

 

The Ogden city council is hoping to diffuse bad feelings in the community and low morale in the police department at its meeting tonight. The council is taking another look at the way raises for both the police and fire department are calculated, an issue that created a protest a week ago.

 

One-on-one, police officers and firefighters are reluctant to say much, but almost everyone in Ogden senses ongoing, low morale in those departments. Recently it got worse because of the way the city council decided to calculate raises for those departments.

 

Out of frustration came a sign on the side of a van, claiming ticket quotas were part of the raise criteria for officers. Things got worse after the police chief suspended an officer tied to the van. The city says Officer Matt Jones' suspension was for something else.

 

The raise issue is evolving this week; the city council may reconsider it, out of fairness.

 

Jesse Garcia, Ogden City Council Chairman: "We should never have a system that brings down the morale of any employee group. They should all be treated fairly."

 

For both police and firefighters, there has always been an issue with the fairness among the rank and file. But some don't feel the issue would have been addressed as quickly if it hadn't been for Officer Jones' situation.

 

In Ogden, city employees have to earn a certain number of points in order to get a five percent raise this year. Because police and fire negotiated their raises separately, more points are required in order to get a five percent raise, plus two percent one-time bonus.

 

Council member Dorrene Jeske says she never liked that deal.

 

Dorrene Jeske, Ogden City Council: "It's punitive. And that's the thing I don't understand from the other council members, they kept saying, we've got to be fair with all groups."

 

City council may change the raise requirements, but the suspension of Officer Jones is still a sore spot for some--possibly political fodder for others. A Weber County investigation into Officer Jones' suspension has not been completed. Mayor Matthew Godfrey requested the probe after allegations he and the police chief were targeting Jones.

 

 

Garden City, police OK contract

The union agrees to no pay raise for first 3 years and 5% raise in last 3 to help cash-strapped city.

From The Detroit News, August 15, 2006

 

GARDEN CITY -- An agreement by the police union to forego pay raises for the first three years of its new labor agreement is essential to helping stabilize Garden City's finances, City Manager David Harvey said.

 

The six-year package, agreed to by the city and police union last week, includes a 5 percent pay increase annually for the last three years of the contract.

 

The city and police union also agreed to allow pay for the equivalent of 30 days of unused sick days to be placed into their pensions.

 

The city also didn't ask for more money in co-pays on prescriptions, which was agreed to in the last contract.

 

"It was one of the keys to help stabilize the budget, an integral part," Harvey said of the pact. "It was important because they have the right to binding arbitration, which is a lengthy and costly process. They worked with me on that."

 

Garden City, like most communities in Michigan, is struggling to balance its budget as revenues shrink. The city spent months seeking to eliminate a $1.8 million deficit in the current budget, which began July 1.

 

Officials blamed the deficit on increases in health care, pensions and gas and cuts in state revenue sharing. Statewide, $1.5 billion has been lost in state revenue sharing over the past five years.

 

To balance the budget, the city decided to move its library to the Maplewood Community Center, then sell the former library to generate revenue.

 

"That was a big move on the council's part," Harvey said. "The financial stress was genuine to do that. After that, they (the unions) were convinced we had (financial) problems."

 

Union President Randy Lorenzetti said the 25 members of the Police Officers of Michigan bargaining unit understood the financial implications and decided to delay the pay raises.

 

"It was the only way we can guarantee a pay raise and help the city at the same time," Lorenzetti said. "It's not that extravagant of a raise, but we wanted to guarantee something."

 

 

Rockford Police Could Ask Voters About Merger with County

From 13 News, August 15, 2006

ROCKFORD -- Rockford's police union explores the possibility of entering into a contract with the county instead. The Police Benevolent and Protective Association met behind closed doors Monday to talk over the possibility of merging the Rockford Police Department with the Winnebago County Sheriff's department.

The PBPA no longer wants to use the term "metro" department to describe the idea of making the two departments one, and it's an idea that got a lot more support than some expected. Union president Sgt. Doug Block says, "I wasn't even asking for a vote. I was just trying to feel the crowd out and there was a motion to take a vote and it was overwhelming to look into the possibility."

To do that, the PBPA will form a special committee to look at the positives and negatives of the proposed merger. And most of the officers at the meeting say they are ready for some kind of drastic change. Union Vice President Aurelio De La Rosa says, "After tonight's response there is definitely enough unity to go forward. So we're going to meet with the city later this week and see what happens."

That meeting on Thursday will be the first negotiation session between the two sides in more than two months. City representatives will present a counter proposal from the last session but union leaders say their membership drew a line in the sand after they saw details on a recent contract that county deputies received, they say, has better pay raises, better retirement options, and better health insurance rates than the city has offered.

Still union leaders remain hopeful that they can reach a final deal at city hall. Block says, "I know there's room for movement on both sides. I got that movement tonight from my membership and hopefully we'll get this thing resolved on Thursday."

That resolution could be pushed by another decision Monday night to seek a shorter contract length because even if a final agreement with the city is reached the PBPA won't stop their push for a merger with the county and that could culminate with a request to put the idea before voters on the ballot this April.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

 

 

Copyright ã POLICEPAY.NET, Inc. 2006 All Rights Reserved

 

 

The POLICEPAY Journal

Published by:

POLICEPAY.NET, Inc.

211 North Robinson Ave, Suite 350

Oklahoma City, OK 73102

(405) 234-2235

www.policepay.net