The POLICEPAY Journal®

Thursday, July 27, 2006

www.policepayjournal.net  

Matt Barnard, Editor   matt@policepay.net    (405) 234-2235    

 

 

INDIANAPOLIS, IN

IPD Officers Vote 'No' To New Contract

NEW ORLEANS, LA

N.O. firefighters union rips Nagin pay plan

BUFFALO, NY

Police union plans ads to press for pay increases

SPRINGFIELD, MA

Union officials say pacts close

BIRMINGHAM, AL

City Council Waits To Decide On First Responder Pay Raises

MENLO PARK, CA

Menlo Park, police agree to labor contract

                                             BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

 

IPD Officers Vote 'No' To New Contract
From WISH-TV, July 27, 2006

A contract that would have meant a pay raise for Indianapolis police officers got shot down Wednesday night. 

FOP President Vince Huber says it was voted down because he wants more money for veteran officers and better pension pay for retirees. It was a close vote with 472 against and 458 for it with the younger officers wanting the pay raise now.

"It's disappointing. It's certainly disappointing but we're more concerned for the officers than we are for any victory for the mayor," said Indianapolis deputy mayor Steve Campbell.

But is this just a continuing battle between Huber and the mayor? "No. I personally don't have anything against the mayor. My goal and responsibility is to get the best contract possible for our members," Huber said.

Some expected the close vote, saying many didn't have all the facts.

"FOP leadership, I don't think they've done a good job getting information out to the body," training instructor Jeff Patterson said.

When members walked in to vote, there was a board right next to the ballot box listing the concerns with the city's offer. You may remember FOP leadership recommended members not accept the contract, but members took it to a vote anyway.

Is there good communication between FOP leadership and membership?

"Yes. It's been improved greatly since I became president," Huber said.

Then why do some feel uninformed? Huber said they have to take some responsibility on their own.

Huber declared impasse giving him the right to call in a federal mediator to work on a contract the FOP considers acceptable.

Deputy Mayor Campbell doesn't think the mayor will come back with a different proposal. "I think we put our best offer on the table."

But does it show the mayor isn't supportive of law enforcement?

"Oh no without question. We've actually put more money into law enforcement every single year since we've been in office," Campbell said.

Huber says this will slow down consolidation. Officers and deputies won't have pay parity.

The mayor's office says that's wishful thinking, saying the sheriff's department and police department will merge as planned.

 

N.O. firefighters union rips Nagin pay plan

From Associated Press, July 27, 2006

NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Mayor Ray Nagin’s new plan to raise police pay across the board, as well as the pay for starting firefighters, did not go over well with leaders of the firefighters’ union.

Seeking to slow an exodus of police and fire personnel since Hurricane Katrina, Nagin announced plans Tuesday to raise salaries by 10 percent for all police officers and to boost the annual starting pay for rookie firefighters by $5,300.

City Council members pledged to implement the plan by Sept. 1. But critics accused the mayor of ignoring the sacrifices made by veteran firefighters since the storm.

Also caught off guard by the announcement was Dr. Jullette Saussy, director of the city’s Emergency Medical Services unit, who said she hoped the omission of ambulance drivers and dispatchers from the pay increase proposal was an “oversight.”

Nagin labeled the move “a first step,” to be followed by an ongoing analysis of how to increase salaries for all firefighters and EMS workers.

“I am committed to taking a look at the entire pay structure of firefighters going forward but right now we are able to fund (only) these raises with our limited resources,” Nagin said.

Nagin said the losses suffered by the Fire Department are not as great as those the Police Department has experienced and could face in the near future as other law enforcement agencies, including State Police, aggressively recruit in New Orleans.

Nagin also noted that firefighters, unlike other municipal workers, benefit from a state-mandated, 2 percent annual pay increase that kicks in during their third year on the job.

Under Nagin’s plan, the Police Department raises would be across the board, boosting pay for every position, from new police recruits to deputy chief to Superintendent Warren Riley.

The salary for a rookie officer still in training would increase from $27,825 to $30,607.

An officer with one year on the job now earns $29,978 a year, plus $3,600 in annual state supplemental pay. With the 10 percent raise, those officers would see their salaries jump to $36,575.

Meanwhile, the annual salary for a new firefighter is slated to increase from $15,519 to $20,800. At its current level, Nagin said, the Fire Department’s starting salary “is just not going to get it done.”

Nagin said the pay package carries a price tag of $2.2 million, which can be covered partially with savings accrued from budgeted but unfilled positions in the police and fire departments, and by dipping into the $3.6 million approved this year by the Legislature to reimburse the city for support services it provides to Harrah’s New Orleans Casino.

The police force stands at 1,452 officers, about 200 fewer than before Katrina. But Riley said 200 or so officers have applied for jobs in other cities.

Fire Superintendent Charles Parent said he has about 680 firefighters on board, about 100 fewer than he had a year ago when the department was already down from its peak strength.

Nick Felton, president of president of the New Orleans Fire Fighters Local 632, said after the news conference that, while he believes police officers deserve a raise, his membership’s patience is wearing thin.

“Morale is already low, and it has just gotten lower,” Felton said. “I can tell you when this news hits firefighters, they’re going to be livid. And they should be.”

 

Police union plans ads to press for pay increases
From The Buffalo News July 25, 2006

 

Buffalo's police union is launching an advertising blitz to try to convince residents that officers are "underpaid, unappreciated and undermined" by a control board that has frozen wages.

The effort, likely to continue for at least a year, will include radio commercials, billboards and community newspaper ads.

Police Benevolent Association President Robert P. Meegan Jr. said the campaign also might include television spots.

"Money is no object at this point in time," said Meegan, noting that union members agreed to a dues increase not long after the control board was created three years ago. "The money was put aside to do battle, so to speak, with the control board."

Mayor Byron W. Brown said that while the union has every right to take its message to the public, he was concerned that some spots appear to use "scare tactics." One radio script, for example, calls the Lower West Side a "war zone" where turf battles among gangs have spurred violence.

"I would hate the public to become frightened, because I think the police have been doing an excellent job," Brown said.

He recited statistics indicating that arrests are up and noted numerous anti-crime efforts since he took office, including the establishment of a cold case squad to investigate long-unsolved homicides.

The police union also announced Monday that it soon will launch yet another legal fight against the control board.

The union already has won a hearing in September on its claim that the 27-month wage freeze gives it the right to strike.

Meegan said the new court battle will challenge the Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority's contention that its active control period won't end until three years after the wage freeze is lifted. Others, including union leaders, insist the board must move into an advisory mode once the city balances three consecutive budgets without deficit borrowing.

"Otherwise, they'll never lift the wage freeze," said Meegan, who accused control board members of trying to extend the life of an authority that he says never should have been established in the first place.

"It's a game they're playing, and it's a very transparent game to the people who are affected by this wage freeze," he said.

Brown said he agrees with the police union on this issue, claiming the state law setting up the control board always assumed that its active oversight role would end after the city balances three consecutive budgets.

The control board declined to comment on the new legal challenge or the union's advertising campaign.

The first round of ads targets the control board. Meegan said the messages, which will change weekly, will aim to "educate" the public on issues that he claimed have been distorted by editorials in The Buffalo News.

In one radio commercial, an announcer asks: "How would you feel if your company said no more raises, and, what's more, you can't strike to gain those rights?"

Brown said he doesn't think the advertising blitz will have any effect whatsoever on ongoing efforts by the city and the police union to devise a plan that would spur the control board to give officers raises. But Meegan has ruled out additional concessions, saying the union already agreed to one-officer patrol cars, schedule changes and other cost-saving moves as part of a 2003 contract.

Brown said he remains cautiously optimistic about forging a plan acceptable to the control board the end of summer.

 

Union officials say pacts close

From The Republican, July 27, 2006

SPRINGFIELD - Union representatives for police officers and firefighters said yesterday they are close to settling long-expired contracts with the Finance Control Board.

Also yesterday, Control Board officials and the Massachusetts Teachers Association conducted a negotiating session to review the association's settlement proposal for a contract for city teachers. Control Board Executive Director Philip Puccia said the sides agreed not to discuss the results of the meeting, which lasted for several hours.

The three unions are the largest labor groups in the city still without a contract. The police and fire contracts expired three years ago.

"I'm very optimistic we will have an agreement soon," said David A. Wells, president of Local 648 of the International Association of Fire Fighters. "It has been a very long, difficult road. I'm hoping the end is in sight."

Thomas M. Scanlon, president of Local 364 of the International Brotherhood of Police Officers, said the sides are getting close to an agreement on the police contract.

"Now it's up to the Control Board," he said. "We have pretty much resolved the major issues."

Puccia agreed that the sides are near settlement. Any agreement would need votes of approval from the union membership.

Most city employees, including police officers, firefighters and teachers, have been under a wage freeze since July 2003.

The union representatives for police and firefighters said that one key remaining contractual issue is a proposal to switch all city employees over to the less expensive state health insurance plan.

Gov. W. Mitt Romney, as part of a bill aimed at expanding the powers of the Control Board, is proposing that Springfield be allowed to transfer health insurance for city employees to the state's Group Insurance Commission, which administers insurance for state employees.

Changing to the state insurance plan could save the city about $4 million in the first year, and reduce the employees' insurance costs by $1.25 million, Puccia said.

Scanlon said the union favors switching to the state plan by adopting an existing state law rather than approving the governor's bill. In addition, the union wants to ensure that existing retirees are not hurt by the transfer, said Scanlon and Wells.

Both union presidents said the long unresolved contracts have hurt morale.

"The frustration has been very high among members, and morale very low," Wells noted.

Teachers have been without a contract since 2002.

Both the Control Board and the teachers' union are waiting for mediator Leslie Williamson to present his fact-finding report, which will contain non-binding recommendations to move past the impasse.

The Control Board plans to implement working conditions for teachers in this fiscal year, based on its proposal, if a settlement is not reached soon.

 

City Council Waits To Decide On First Responder Pay Raises

From NBC13.com, July 25, 2006

 

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. -- Birmingham's City Council has voted to table the issue of pay raises for police and firefighters.

 

Several councilors told NBC13 Tuesday they would vote to pass the plan. Some said the raise is necessary because city responders are leaving to go to higher paying jobs in other cities.

 

Other councilors said they want more time to talk to the parties involved. They will take up the issue again in five weeks.

 

At that time, the council would need to recommend the raise to the Jefferson County Personnel Board.

 

If the increase passes, it would be a 15 percent raise over the next three years and would take effect during the next fiscal year.

 

Menlo Park, police agree to labor contract
Salary increases for the city's 37 line officers; pension rates unchanged
From the Palo Alto Almanac, July 25, 2006

After 10 bargaining sessions and two meetings with a state mediator, the Menlo Park Police Officers Association and the city have negotiated a new two-year labor contract.

The agreement includes increases in wages and health insurance coverage for the 37 officers represented by the association.

Both issues proved difficult during negotiations, and a state mediator was "instrumental" in getting the two sides to reach an agreement, said Glen Kramer, the city's personnel director.

The new agreement will boost the average line officer's monthly salary from about $6,572 to about $6,835 a 4 percent increase. The figure doesn't include benefits.

The new rate puts Menlo Park's officers at "pretty much average" pay compared with nearby cities, Mr. Kramer said.

"We feel the needs of the employees have been met, and we've stayed within the cost constraints of the city," Mr. Kramer said.

The agreement also calls for the city to pay about 12 percent more of officers' health insurance costs.

For example, the city currently provides about $988 per month for costs associated with a family health insurance plan, and the contract calls for that figure to increase to about $1,106.

Officers will continue to receive the state's top pension rate, Mr. Kramer said. At age 50 they can retire and receive 90 percent of their highest annual salary if they have worked 30 years or more as an officer.

"We can certainly live with this agreement," said John Noble, a labor relations consultant representing the police officers association from the Pleasant Hill-based law firm of Rains, Lucia and Wilkinson.

The agreement was reached July 17, about a month after both parties declared impasse and called in a state mediator.

The City Council is scheduled to consider the agreement at its meeting Tuesday, July 25. If approved by the council, the salary increases will be retroactive to July 1.

The council is scheduled to meet at 7 p.m. in the council chambers at the Civic Center, between Laurel and Alma streets.

 

 

 

BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

 

 

Copyright ã POLICEPAY.NET, Inc. 2006 All Rights Reserved

 

 

The POLICEPAY Journal

Published by:

POLICEPAY.NET, Inc.

211 North Robinson Ave, Suite 350

Oklahoma City, OK 73102

(405) 234-2235

www.policepay.net