The POLICEPAY Journal®

Thursday, May 31, 2007

JOIN THE POLICEPAY Journal Mailing List 

Matt Barnard, Editor   matt@policepay.net    (405) 701-8616  

LAS VEGAS SEMINAR

POWER, INFLUENCE & PERSUASION

POLICE CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS FOR THE 21ST CENTURY       OCTOBER 25 & 26, 2007

CLICK HERE FOR INFORMATION

SAN FRANCISCO, CA

SFPD officers to see pay increase

SAN ANTONIO, TX

Police, firefighters OK new pacts

NASHVILLE, TN

Unions say Purcell would break pay raise promise

HAWAII

Police ecstatic over contract

SUNRISE, FL

By 3-1 vote, Sunrise OKs police contract

MOORE, OK

Moore officials, police union ink new contract

HOUSTON, TX

HPD lures recruits with low cost of living, bonuses

                                             BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

POLICEPAY.NET SERVICES

(Click on service name for information and pricing)

CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS  NEGOTIATIONS RESEARCH

 

SFPD officers to see pay increase

From the Examiner, May 30, 2007

 

SAN FRANCISCO -

San Francisco police officers are in line to receive a 23 percent salary hike during a four-year period, according to the terms of a recently negotiated contract.

 

With the double-digit salary increase, The City’s police salary costs would increase next fiscal year alone by $9 million, from the $263 million spent on police compensation this year.

 

On July 1, the beginning of the next fiscal year, wages for The City’s 2,237 police officers — from frontlines officers up to deputy chiefs — would increase by 4 percent on July 1. First-year officers, who are paid about $65,000, would receive an additional 4 percent raise — for a combined 8 percent raise — on July 1.

 

On Dec. 29, an across-the-board raise of 2 percent would kick in and salaries would increase again in the first half of each of the subsequent three fiscal years by 7 percent, 6 percent and 4 percent.

 

“It’s a market wage. We didn’t give them more than what the market dictated,” said Steve Ponder, compensation manager with The City’s Department of Human Resources.

 

The current four-year contract, which expires June 30, had granted pay raises totaling 15.2 percent, according to Ponder.

 

Mayor Gavin Newsom’s Chief of Staff Phil Ginsburg said The City is losing about 115 officers a year, mostly to retirement, and there is a need to stay competitive in terms of compensation to be able to recruit and retain officers. The City aims not only to backfill those positions, but also add more police officers, he said. Ginsburg said police departments nationwide are losing a large number of officers to retirement.

 

Ginsburg praised the contract for including a pilot program to encourage officers to live in The City by offering up to $20,000 as a forgivable loan for first-time homebuyers and $5,000 for rental or relocation assistance.


The total increase in compensation for the police officers in the next fiscal year is valued at about $13.6 million, but cost savings negotiated into the contract — such as restrictions on the use of overtime and the decrease in the number of sick-leave hours that can be cashed out — is expected to offset the cost to The City and lower the price tag to about $9 million. Supervisor Sean Elsbernd, who chairs the Government Audit and Oversight Committee, which will hold the board’s first hearing on the contract, said he supports the contract because it will make the Police Department’s salaries more competitive with neighboring cities.

 

“Our police officers are 11 percent underfunded when you compare them to other jurisdictions in the Bay Area,” Elsbernd said. “If we are going to recruit officers into the finest police department in the country, we’ve got to pay them appropriately.”

 

Supervisor Chris Daly said he is against the contract. “The mayor wants to hand a golden contract to the POA in an election year. It’s good politics for Gavin Newsom but bad public policy,” Daly said. He added, “I think it’s a little bit too much given all the other competing priorities in the budget.”

 

Police Officers’ Association President Gary Delagnes characterized the salary increase as fair and equitable. “It puts us at a level where we are going to be able to compete with San Jose and Oakland,” Delagnes said. “We believe The City stepped up and did the right thing.

 

The Board of Supervisors Government Audit and Oversight Committee may vote on the contract as soon as June 11.

 

Police, firefighters OK new pacts

From the Express-New, May 25, 2007

 

After months of legal and political wrangling, police and firefighters will see health care changes and pay raises, and Police Chief William McManus will enjoy significantly more freedom in choosing his top staff under collective bargaining agreements overwhelmingly approved Friday.

 

The police contract also grants McManus at least six new leadership positions.

The passage comes after initial contracts failed by large margins in November, firefighters filed a lawsuit alleging the city wasn't bargaining in good faith and police officers set up a Web site slamming some components of their contract.

 

Much of the criticism focused on the city's early attempts to increase the amount firefighters and police pay for health care.

 

But the heads of both the fire and police unions Friday said they were pleased with the final results.

 

"It's very good," said Teddy Stewart, president of the San Antonio Police Officers Association. However, he conceded: "You're going to have a vocal minority of people who are going to be unhappy with everything."

 

Chris Steele, who heads the San Antonio Professional Firefighters Association and has criticized the city's dealings with his union in the past, called the contract "proof that (City Manager Sheryl Sculley) really does care for the firefighters."

 

Of those who voted, 72 percent of police officers favored their contract and firefighters approved theirs by a landslide of 95.56 percent.

 

In a statement, Sculley called the agreement a "great accomplishment" and said it will "allow us to focus our attention on further improving the high level of service."

 

On the police side, an initially contentious part of the contract expands McManus' oversight by giving him at least six new commander positions to head each of the city's substations — at a total cost of $1.1 million.

 

Captains currently direct those stations, but McManus wanted to appoint higher-ranking commanders as leaders, arguing it would make them more accountable to him and to the city.

 

Civil service rules constrict how and where you can move officers who have been promoted to certain ranks; for instance, captains who don't perform to satisfaction can't necessarily be demoted.

 

Appointed commanders, however, aren't bound by such constraints. They also can work longer, tailor-made hours and aren't bound by contract rules that require captains to work specific hours.

 

"The chief was looking to move away from that and get more command in the field and at night," said Capt. William Smith who represented McManus during the negotiations and helped push the proposal.

 

McManus said in a statement that the "24/7 operation" of running a substation, overseeing dozens of patrol officers and detectives and dealing with the increasing community relations aspect necessitates a "greater level of authority" that the commander rank would provide.

 

The proposed new leadership drew the ire of many rank-and-file officers, who balked at yet another level of management at a time of chronic shortages in the numbers of patrol officers and detectives working the streets.

 

To appease those concerns, police union leaders pushed for a clause that would keep McManus from appointing any commanders until 200 more officers are out on the street and the department measures a strength of 2,194.

 

To reach that number is difficult, however, because training must keep pace with the hiring of new officers, Smith said. Also, 113 officers currently have served 30 years or more, considered the ideal retirement age, he said.

 

"As you try to fill the bucket, you see the hole," Smith said.

 

Still, he characterized the situation as a "win-win," one that would give the city "an incentive to fill those positions, which are badly needed, and give better and more effective direction in the field."

 

McManus also will have more latitude in making his appointments — previously, chiefs only could pick from the rank below the position they wanted to fill, but now he can choose from two ranks below.

 

Those constraints were highlighted when McManus made his first major appointment to replace outgoing Assistant Chief Jerry Pittman and only could pick from his five deputy chief slots.

 

Other changes in the contracts mean officers will see a 14 percent pay raise over the next three years and firefighters a 15 percent raise over the next four years.

 

A significant part of the negotiations revolved around health care costs; specifically, city leaders initially pushed to have firefighters and police pay monthly health care premiums.

 

Ultimately, the new contracts do not require them to pay those premiums; however, monthly payments to their retirement health care fund will increase significantly.

 

Police and firefighters currently pay about $70 a month to that fund but under the new increases, could pay up to about $200. They'll also shoulder higher out-of-pocket expenses, see increased deductibles and be required to seek only in-network medical care.

 

Newly appointed Fire Chief Charles Hood said the relief of having the contract finalized is tremendous.

 

"Now we can focus on what we need to get done," he said.

 

 

Unions say Purcell would break pay raise promise

From the Nashville City Paper, May 31, 2007

 

Several local unions are agitated with Mayor Bill Purcell, crying foul over his suggestion that Metro not provide step pay increases for more than 3,600 Metro employees this year.

The Purcell administration, however, is emphasizing it would offer an across-the-board 3 percent pay increase for all Metro employees this year — better than the 2 percent originally proposed — and says it is doing the best it can with a limited budget.

The Metro Council will have the final say on the matter — the city’s budget ordinance is scheduled for a public hearing before the legislative body next Tuesday — and at least three local unions, the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP), the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) and the Teamsters have begun lobbying Council members to retain the step increases this year.

The Teamsters say Purcell promised — under the city’s current pay plan — to fund a 3 percent step increase for police officers for three consecutive years beginning in the 2005-2006 fiscal year. These annual step increases would sit atop a series of across-the-board pay increases most other Metro employees would receive — 3 percent in the 2005-2006 fiscal year, 2 percent during 2006-2007 and 2 percent this coming fiscal year, beginning July 1.

The Metro Civil Service Commission voted 3-2 yesterday to pass Purcell’s proposed pay plan so that it could be sent to the Metro Council for consideration. The action follows an April 11 letter Metro Finance Director David Manning sent the Council explaining the situation. In the letter, Manning says if the revised pay plan is not approved, city departments would have to cut jobs.

“Total losses across all agencies are 108.4 jobs. The largest reductions occur in the area of public safety and health, which would experience 54.2 jobs lost. The Mayor did not find this level of job loss to be acceptable in this budget. The revised pay plan will allow Metro to avoid all of these job losses,” read Manning’s letter.

Today, Teamsters Local 327 — which represents Metro Police officers at the bargaining table — sent Council members a letter reacting to the Civil Service Commission vote, expressing sharp frustration with Purcell.

“At a time when [Metro Police officers] are more productive and accountable than ever before and manpower is arguably at the lowest level in years this is an insult. The men and women of the police department literally fight daily for the safety of you and your constituents. The increment raise was promised by the council and the Mayor in 2005,” the letter says.

“Recruiting and retention in Nashville is at an all-time low. With support from a mayor like this it is no wonder. Separate yourself from this lame duck administration and stand up for your police.”

Roy Dunaway, a police officer and the 327’s liaison to the Police Department, said the union is concerned Purcell’s proposal would eliminate one year of the current officers’ 10-year step-pay program and said the union believes Metro is under a contractual obligation to provide the step increase.

Molly Sudderth, Mayor Bill Purcell’s spokeswoman, said the proposal would only put the step increase off a year — not eliminate it — and said Purcell made the choice he felt was best for the city as a whole.

“I think the mayor was trying to do the best he could do for Metro employees, and he felt, after looking at what it would cost to fund step increases versus what it will cost to fund a 3 percent pay increase across the board — he determined that a 3 percent pay increase across the board would be the best course of action."

 

 

Police ecstatic over contract

From the Star-Bulletin, May 25, 2007

 

Union, police and county officials hailed the arbitrator-set pay raises for police officers in Hawaii yesterday as a step in the right direction toward recruiting and retaining more qualified officers.

 

"That will definitely motivate officers," said Tenari Maafala, Honolulu Police Department officer and board president of the State of Hawaii Organization of Police Officers.

 

Honolulu Police Chief Boisse Correa agreed.

 

"This will get us closer to parity with other jurisdictions throughout the nation," he said.

 

Maafala said police officers in Hawaii earn 22 percent to 23 percent less than counterparts on the West Coast.

 

With annual 6 percent increases for four years, as spelled out in the arbitrator's award announced yesterday, police officers' pay will be 26 percent higher at the end of the contract.

 

Officer's pay on the mainland is also expected to increase.

 

"I think given where we are today to where we were two or three years ago, it's a heck of a lot better," said Honolulu Mayor Mufi Hannemann.

 

Other provisions in the contract also help.

 

Officers will continue to get pay raises as they reach the next-higher step in years of service.

 

Those with at least 25 years of service will get an additional 4.3 percent raise in the first year of the contract, thanks to the creation of a new step. Right now, officers reach their highest salary in a particular pay grade after 22 years of service.

 

Correa said HPD retains only 3 percent to 4 percent of officers with at least 25 years of service.

 

In addition, the starting salary for recruits will increase to a little more than $42,000 per year from approximately $38,000, Maafala said. By the end of the contract, starting pay for a recruit will be more than $52,000.

 

In January the monthly allowance for officers who use their own cars for work will go up to $600 for patrol officers and $562 for detectives and those in special units. The current allowance is $488 and $530, respectively.

 

Officers will receive a 20-cent-per-hour boost in their differential pay -- in recognition that police cannot take certain part-time jobs because of their standards of conduct -- in the second year of the contract. They also won reinstatement of their $720 annual uniform and firearm allowance in the third year.

 

Maafala said the majority of the comments he has received from officers about the contract have been positive.

 

Officer Bryson Ponce, SHOPO Kauai Chapter chairman, said Kauai police officers he has talked to are really happy with the award.

 

"You hear comments like 'unprecedented,' 'great job,'" Ponce sa

 

 

By 3-1 vote, Sunrise OKs police contract

From the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, May 27, 2007

 

Sunrise · Despite statewide tax reforms that may put the city in a financial squeeze, commissioners have approved a three-year employment contract with the police officers' union calling for raises and benefits costing an average of $1.5 million more annually.

The deal, which received final approval on Tuesday, ends a contentious negotiation process in which groups of officers intermittently appeared at commission meetings to express their disdain for growing pension costs. Some commissioners and the president of the officers' union praised the contract as an effective way to entice new police officers to the department. The contract was passed 3-1, with Commissioner Joseph Scuotto absent.

Mayor Steven Feren cast the dissenting vote, considering new information regarding the state tax proposals.

During the first reading on May 8, Feren had voiced his concern that the contract might overextend the city in a time of financial uncertainty. In a telephone interview after that meeting, Feren said he wound up tentatively voting in favor of the contract because he supported the police, and he realized that voting against it would be futile given that a majority of commissioners appeared to support it.

"My concern is that we have to find $1.5 million more to pay this contract," Feren said at the time. "I'm very concerned about what the [state] Legislature is going to do and how bad it's going to be" for the city.

At the May 8 meeting, Feren had proposed a motion to postpone a vote on the contract until after the state Legislature's special session this summer on property taxes, but it died for lack of a second vote.

Commissioner Roger Wishner criticized Feren for raising concerns at the last minute. Wishner said the contract would help fill 18 vacancies and retain the department's complement of 133 sworn police officers. "We cannot afford not paying our police officers [more] with other communities stealing away our officers," Wishner said.

Mike Broksch, president of the Fraternal Order of Police's Sunrise chapter, hailed the contract as a breakthrough.

Under the contract, all officers would receive 5 percent raises annually; and some officers would receive an additional 5 percent merit-based raise annually. All would contribute 9.84 percent of their annual salaries to cover pension costs.

"I feel the commissioners have addressed some of the problems in our department. This is a generous package," Broksch said.

 

 

Moore officials, police union ink new contract

From The Norman Transcript, May 30, 2007


MOORE -- Moore police officers will see their pay increase by more than 4 percent under a contract approved by the city council earlier this month.

Endorsed by a 7-0 vote during the council's May 21 meeting, the new contract inceases the base pay level for officers by 4.39 percent. That amount, city manager Steve Eddy said, is designed to keep pace with Oklahoma City's pay scale.

"We try to keep our pay in line with Oklahoma City's pay scale. Right now, we're one year behind."

For example, police officers with one to seven years' experience would see their pay increase by about $2,035 per year. A built-in merit pay step increase would add another $1,050 to the officer's pay -- for a total increase of about $3,085 per year.

Those figures, he said, parallel Oklahoma City's 2006-2007 pay scale.

The contract also increases an officer's longevity pay from $172 to $1,148 annually, depending on the number of years service.

"That averages out to about $1,400 for an officer who's been here five years," said city finance director Jim Corbett.

Along with the pay increases, Corbett said the contract calls for police to accept an 11 percent increase in the cost of their health insurance -- about $20 per month.

Currently, the city pays 75 percent of the insurance costs for employees or employees and their family members.

Educational incentives, Corbett said, also were increased.

"We want to encourage education," he said. "And the incentives are a way to do that."

Officers with advanced degrees receive a monthly stipend -- $50 for an associate's degree, $75 for a bachelor's degree and $100 for a master's degree.

Under the contract's new terms, those amounts would increase by $25 for each degree.

In addition to the city's educational incentives, the contract details the limitations on the city's life insurance coverage.

Under the policy, police officers received life insurance equal to 1.5 times their salary. However, that coverage is capped at $150,000.

"We wanted to make it clear that it (the city's life insurance policy) maxes out at $150,000 in life insurance coverage," Corbett said. "We have some salaries that are coming close to the $100,000 range and wanted to make clear there is a maximum."

Eddy said city officials were pleased with the neogtiations.

"Negotiation with the FOP team went well," he said, in a memo to city council members. "It was a real simple contact for us this year, virtually all of it had to do with monetary issues."

Moore employs 73 police officers and a five-member police support staff. The city's new budget -- approved at the same council meeting -- calls for the addition of three new police positions.

 

HPD lures recruits with low cost of living, bonuses
Police officers across the nation apply to HPD, but Dallas offers more attractive bonuses

From the Houston Chronicle, May 28, 2007

 

Eight years into his career as a New York police officer in Brooklyn, Daniel McNeil draws a salary that's more than twice the base pay of a rookie cop in Houston.

 

The cost of living in New York, however, has become so restrictive that McNeil is looking for police work in Houston and Dallas, where the respective departments are in head-to-head competition for nationwide recruits.

 

"The dollar goes a lot further down here," said McNeil, 38, who was among 500 people to take the Houston Police Department's civil service examination last month at the George R. Brown Convention Center.

 

While he is considering both of Texas' largest cities, McNeil would prefer to move to Houston because his wife has friends who relocated here to escape New York's high living costs. But he's open to the Dallas Police Department because it offers a $10,000 signing bonus.

 

That bonus — $3,000 bigger than what is offered in Houston — is cited as a big reason that the Dallas Police Department employs a record number of officers. That department has 3,065 officers, and it is on track to add up to 350 more this year.

 

Dallas has about 2.8 officers per 1,000 residents, but its goal is to reach 3 officers per 1,000 residents by year's end, said head recruiter Lt. Tammy Hill.

 

HPD, by comparison, has 2.1 officers per 1,000 residents, with a goal of 2.8 officers per 1,000 residents. HPD would have to hire 700 more officers to reach that goal of 5,500.

 

The two cities' competition to fill their ranks is intense.

 

Unlike its counterparts around the country, HPD does not plan to offer signing bonuses to rookie recruits, said Frank Rusinski, head of the department's recruiting efforts.

 

Bonuses for recruits

 

The majority of HPD recruits, however, are new to police work, and departments across the country are offering $5,000 to $10,000 bonuses to bring in new cadets. Five of seven HPD academy classes last year were for rookies.

 

HPD's $7,000 signing bonus is only offered to lateral recruits with previous law enforcement experience, said HPD Sgt. Nate McDuell. The lateral cadet classes, however, accounted for about 15 percent of enrolled cadets last year.

 

Rookie cadets in Houston start off at $29,164 during a probationary period. HPD's base pay is $36,022, while Dallas' base pay is $41,000. The Dallas City Council increased it from $39,000 last year.

 

"By upping our salary and offering a bonus, we're trying to make Dallas more attractive to applicants," said Hill, the Dallas recruiter.

 

McNeil makes $80,000 in Brooklyn, but he's willing to take a reasonable pay cut to live in Texas.

 

Also, since 2004, Dallas police added nine investigators to check applicant backgrounds. While many departments take up to six months to conduct background checks, Dallas completes its checks in about two months.

 

"That's significant because recruiters are bringing them in, so you want to process applications faster," Hill said.

 

Though its force is not where officials say it should be, HPD did see a net gain in officers last year.

 

In 2006, the Houston department lost 222 officers to retirements, terminations and resignations, but it added 325 cadets for a net gain of 103 officers, McDuell said.

 

But Dallas' gains were bigger. Hill said Dallas PD had a net gain of 218 and expects to gain more than 330 this year.

 

Most are from Texas

 

While HPD is recruiting from across the country, the vast majority of qualified recruits who enter the police academy — 93 percent — are from Texas. About 84 percent are from the Houston metropolitan area.

 

"It's something I've always wanted to do," said Houstonian Syed Izhar, 32, who took the entrance exam last month.

 

Izhar is studying criminal justice at Remington College's Houston campus to acquire the 60 college credit hours HPD requires to enter the academy. Dallas requires 45 hours of college credit for cadets.

 

Both departments waive the college requirement for applicants with military service.

The most recent HPD exam attracted recruits from New York, Michigan, Oklahoma, Lubbock and elsewhere.

 

"I just wish they could pay him his New York salary," said McNeil's wife, Nara, as she stood in the convention center lobby while her husband was taking the 30-question exam.

 

"We've got friends in Houston, and there's no state income tax, so it would be a nice place to live," McNeil said after the exam. "And," added Nara McNeil, "we could finally afford to buy a house."

 

BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

 

 

Copyright ã POLICEPAY.NET, Inc. 2007 All Rights Reserved

 

 

The POLICEPAY Journal

Published by:

POLICEPAY.NET, Inc.

219 West Boyd St, Suite 205

Norman, OK 73069

(405) 701-8616

www.policepay.net