The POLICEPAY Journal®

Thursday, April 12, 2007

JOIN THE POLICEPAY Journal Mailing List 

Matt Barnard, Editor   matt@policepay.net    (405) 701-8616  

UPCOMING POLICEPAY.NET SEMINAR’S                     

CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS         -      May 1st Los Angeles Area

CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS         -     May 3rd  San Francisco Area

SAN DIEGO, CA

Police officers OK 9% pay raise

INDIANAPOLIS, IN

Tentative pact reported for metro police, city

YOUNGSTOWN, OH

Parking changes irk police union

NEW YORK, NY

Mike says exodus talk just a cop out

SALINAS, CA

City caps week of police raises

                                             BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

POLICEPAY.NET SERVICES

(Click on service name for information and pricing)

CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS  NEGOTIATIONS RESEARCH

 

Police officers OK 9% pay raise

1-year deal includes revision in benefits

From the UNION-TRIBUNE, April 11, 2007

 

SAN DIEGO – An overwhelming number of San Diego police officers voted in favor of a new one-year contract yesterday that gives most of them a 9 percent raise.

Health benefits also are revamped under the contract, which Mayor Jerry Sanders is expected to announce today.

 

Negotiators from the Mayor's Office and the police union have worked on the deal since mid-January. It came together Monday, thanks to some last-minute concessions from both sides.

 

Six percent of the pay increase – the first raise issued by the city in about two years – kicks in July 1. Two percent will be added at the end of the year.

 

About 80 percent of the officers are eligible for the final 1 percent, which is based on a formula that factors in education and experience.

 

While the increase to pay and benefits will cost the city about $16 million starting July 1, Sanders expects to save about $3 million annually by consolidating health care plans and eliminating a workers' compensation benefit for police.

 

Mostly, though, the mayor said the agreement should offset an ongoing recruitment and retention problem within the Police Department.

 

“I'm happy we have a contract, but this was market-driven,” Sanders said yesterday from his office. “I think we've made some pretty good strides in moving the officers up, competitively, with other agencies.”

 

The agreement comes as Sanders prepares to announce his $2.88 billion operating budget Friday. He is balancing that budget, in part, by eliminating 369 vacant positions and laying off 302 employees.

 

The police union initially asked for a 14 percent raise, according to the mayor, who said his first offer was pretty close to what was agreed to.

 

“I wanted the officers to know I was serious. Our goal was not to play games,” said Sanders, who was the city's police chief from 1993 until 1999.

 

For the last two years, police have had one-year contracts imposed on them.

 

“I felt we needed an agreement,” Sanders said. “A lot of citizens have told me public safety should be your No. 1 priority, you're losing a lot of cops and services aren't the same.”

 

So Sanders signed off on the final 1 percent Monday, the same day the union agreed to drop a benefit that covers police financially if they hurt themselves while working out on their own time. The perk has cost the city $15 million in claims since 1999.

 

The concessions were the final pieces to a deal that union leaders took to their members yesterday in five separate meetings, most of which were standing room only.

 

More than half of union's 1,900 members voted on the contract, which passed with an 85 percent majority, said Sgt. Bill Nemec, union president.

 

“The negotiations were tough,” Nemec said. “But both sides were committed to do what was best for the city and for the officers.”

 

Some of the rank and file saw the deal as a positive first step.

 

“There wasn't anyone cheering or anything,” said Sgt. Bob Dare, who was at the first early morning session, which drew about 100 officers.

 

Sgt. Dan Ellison, who was impressed with the contract, said the past few years for police officers had been as bad as he's seen it.

 

“I hope this is a shot in the arm for morale,” he said as he stood outside the police union headquarters in Kearny Mesa.

 

Detective Sgt. Jim Arthur said that considering the city's financial situation – which includes an unfunded liability of $2.4 billion for pension benefits and retiree health care – he had no problem with the proposal.

 

Officer Jeff Jordon, a union board member and a member of the negotiating team, said the proposal sent a message that the city and the mayor were serious about retaining officers.

 

Fully-staffed, the Police Department employs 2,108 officers, but only 1,874 are on the payroll.

 

In the past eight months, the department has lost 129 officers, including 54 who took jobs with other law enforcement agencies, said assistant chief William Maheu.

 

The contract should help offset some of the department's recruiting and retention problems, Maheu said.

 

“I'm ecstatic,” he said. “Obviously, it's not perfect. But you've got to do these things one step at a time.”

 

Although the deal appears to close the gap on some of the issues police have, the agreement could lead to a new set of headaches for Sanders and his negotiators.

 

Unions representing deputy city attorneys and firefighters are expected to wrap up contract talks with the city this week. Two others, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Local 127 and the Municipal Employees Association, are entering the final year of their deals.

 

Local 127 and MEA members, the city's blue-and white-collar workers, will receive a 4 percent raise July 1, the beginning of the city's new fiscal year.

 

Both unions, however, have a clause in their contract that says if another bargaining unit gets a higher raise, they can force the city back into negotiations.

 

Howard Guess, president of MEA, declined to comment last night because he hadn't seen the agreement.

 

Joan Raymond, president of Local 127, said the police raise was “great for them, but I think our people deserve just as much of a raise as the police,” Raymond said. “We took a 2 percent pay cut two years ago to help the city out.”

 

Frank De Clercq , vice president of the firefighters union, said he's not impressed with the deal.

 

Along with the police contract, the mayor plans to unveil his public safety budget proposals today.

 

About $571 million will be spent on police and fire during fiscal 2008. That's about 9 percent more than the current year.

 

The Police Department is slated to get $390 million, compared to $360 million during the current fiscal year. The bulk of the increase covers the pay and benefit increases for officers and other police personnel.

 

The San Diego Fire-Rescue Department would receive about $181 million under the mayor's proposal, compared to $170 million this year. About $5 million has been set aside for equipment upgrades, and most of the rest is being used to cover an increase in retirement and retiree health care contributions. That means nothing is left for pay raises.

 

Fire officials said the department still needed about $12.5 million for repairs and maintainance at fire stations and lifeguard facilities.

 

The only unmet need facing the Police Department, Maheu said, was hiring more personnel.

 

“The one thing I want more than anything else is people,” he said.

 

 

Tentative pact reported for metro police, city

From the Indianapolis Star, April 10, 2007

 

Union negotiators for the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department and the city have hammered out a tentative contract -- the first contract for the newly merged law enforcement agency.

 

It gives no salary increase for 2007 but includes increases for the next three years of the four-year contract: 3 percent in 2008, 4 percent in 2009 and 5 percent in 2010, according to an update posted on the police union's Internet site.

 

Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 86 represents about 2,300 active and retired law enforcement officers from Marion County. Previously, that meant officers from the Indianapolis Police Department and the Marion County Sheriff's Department.

Those agencies merged Jan. 1.

 

Contract negotiations began in 2005 and have been contentious. Among the issues were retroactive pay for 2006 and achieving pay parity between city and county officers. It was unclear Monday whether or how those issues were worked out.

 

The FOP Internet update says the terms would be effective retroactively to Jan. 1 upon passage by the membership, but it did not indicate when there would be a vote.

 

Messages left for FOP President Aaron Sullivan and Kevin Murray, legal adviser for Marion County Sheriff Frank Anderson, were not returned.

 

 

Parking changes irk police union

The city's 'hostile stance is unreasonable,' the union president says.

From the Youngstown Vindicator, April 9, 2007

 

YOUNGSTOWN — The president of the Youngstown police patrolmen's union describes contract talks as "terrible," specifically saying the city administration's decision to eliminate most of the patrolmen's parking spots at the city hall lot as "an indication as to how bad negotiations are going."

 

The Youngstown Police Association, representing 117 patrolmen, not only filed a grievance over the city's decision to take away 18 of its 28 spots in the lot on the corner of West Boardman and Hazel streets, it took the city to court seeking a temporary restraining order.

 

Magistrate Eugene J. Fehr of Mahoning County Common Pleas Court denied the order but agreed to hear the union's request for a preliminary injunction at an April 18 hearing to get back the 18 parking spots.

 

The union's contract expired Nov. 30, 2006, and the parties are far from an agreement, said Edward Colon, YPA president.

 

Mayor Jay Williams said negotiations are "progressing."

 

Both sides agree the union's contract calls for the city to provide "free, secure and ample" parking for the patrolmen. For the past nine years, those parking spots were in the city hall lot.

 

But that has changed.

 

What happened

 

The YPA received letters Jan. 21 and March 19 from Sean McKinney, the city's buildings and grounds commissioner, that its members were no longer permitted to park in the lot and any unauthorized vehicles would be towed. A grievance filed by the union was rejected.

 

The city backed off from its original position and is permitting the YPA to keep 10 parking spots and unauthorized vehicles won't be towed while the matter goes to arbitration, Williams said. The city recently erected signs for the former YPA spots designating them for other departments.

 

The city made improvements, including fencing and a security system to stop unauthorized access, to its parking lot on South Phelps Street, just south of the city hall annex. There are numerous spots for city employees, including YPA members at that lot, Williams said. The use of the lot next to the annex complies with the parking language in the police contract, Williams said.

 

Because the city guarantees free parking to about half of its city hall employees, it is reconfiguring the city hall lot to add more spots, Williams said. That will enable more city workers to park in that lot instead of having the city pay monthly fees for them to park elsewhere, he said.

 

Spots in the city hall lot are needed during peak work times between 8 a.m. and 4 p.m., and police officers who work during off-peak hours can park there, Williams said.

 

Effort seen as insult

 

Colon sees the move as an insult to the patrolmen.

 

"We thought the decision was a little unprofessional," he said. "I'm disappointed with the way they treated us. To take a hostile stance is unreasonable. It takes away our sense of belonging to the city that they would do this to us. It creates a morale issue.  It's a shame the city took such a hard stance."

 

The patrolmen are required to carry their gear and duty bag, including their weapons, to work each day, Colon said. The gear and bag weighs between 75 and 90 pounds and puts a strain on officers who have to carry it to the police station from the annex parking lot rather than the one next to city hall, he said.

 

"I reject claims of mistreatment out of hand. There are 100 free spots two blocks away at the city annex lot," Williams said. "There's a difference of opinion here. Seeking a restraining order was the most disappointing thing."

 

The city is doing nothing to mistreat or disrespect the patrolmen, Williams said.

 

Arbitration

 

Colon said the city's edict to take away most of the patrolmen's parking spots during the negotiation process left the union with no other choice but to file for a restraining order. The city should have permitted an arbitrator to determine which side was correct before taking away most of the patrolmen's spots at the city hall lot and its initial hard-line position, he said. An arbitrator should have a decision on the parking issue in about a month, he said.

 

Also, the union and the city will go to fact-finding, scheduled for May 7, to resolve the contract dispute, Colon said.

 

The parking issue "sets the tone for negotiations and fact-finding," Colon said. "It will have a substantial impact on this and future negotiations."

 

 

Mike says exodus talk just a cop out

It's a tough job, but there's no NYPD flood to nearby towns

From the DAILY NEWS, April 7th 2007

 

It's harder to be a cop in New York City than anywhere else, Mayor Bloomberg declared yesterday as he rejected claims by police union leaders that cops have been quitting in droves to work for suburban departments.

 

"There's no question it's easier to be a police officer outside of the NYPD than in," Bloomberg said on his weekly WABC-AM radio show. "The NYPD is the most demanding police department in the world. That's why it's the best."

 

Bloomberg said a "handful" of cops leave each year for suburban police departments, but he insisted neighboring departments are too small to absorb a large number of city cops.

 

"If [suburban departments] pay so well, people that get there aren't going to retire," Bloomberg said. "So, this business that everybody is leaving for these other police departments is just a bunch of PR."

 

But a spokesman from the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association said more than 4,000 "experienced and expensively trained" cops resigned from the NYPD during the past five years. "That's resigned not retired," the spokesman said.

 

Meanwhile, Bloomberg acknowledged that NYPD officers are increasingly turning down promotions to sergeant because the pay raise isn't big enough.

 

Under the contract imposed by a state arbitration panel in 2005, rookie cops are paid $25,100 a year while in the academy. Their maximum base pay tops out at $59,588 after seven years.

 

Sergeants earn just $61,093 - not even $2,000 a year more to compensate them for the increased responsibilities.

 

"Perhaps some people say, 'Well I don't want the extra responsibility.' So, fewer people are taking" the sergeant's exam, Bloomberg said.

 

Bloomberg said he could not explain why a smaller percentage of cops passed the Feb. 3 sergeants exam, as compared to the last exam in December 2003.

 

But the mayor insisted the city will not ease its standards.

 

"We want the best trained police officers - the public has a right to them," he said.

 

 

City caps week of police raises
Council OKs salary bumps
From

 

Salinas city officials Friday gave police officers a significant raise - a move intended to attract new officers and retain the help needed to stem gang violence and support community-based peace efforts.

 

The City Council agreed to a 25 percent pay raise for officers over the next two and a half years.

 

A memorandum of understanding signed with the Salinas Police Officers Association will give them a 5 percent pay increase retroactive to April 1, then additional 5 percent raises every six months through the end of 2009.

 

Additionally, effective in July, officers with 20 years of service with the Salinas

Police Department will get an additional 5 percent bonus.

 

The Friday move follows a City Council decision Tuesday to approve a separate MOU approved by the police management union granting near-identical raises to police management, including deputy chiefs, commanders and sergeants. Chief Dan Ortega is not included in this group.

 

All told, the raise agreements reached this week will cost the city $4.5 million through the duration of the pacts.

 

Under the agreement with the police officers union, annual pay for an entry-level officer will jump from $63,690 to $77,760 by the end of 2009. At the top level, annual pay will rise from $81,648 to $99,240.

 

"If you're a good, competent, well-trained officer, we want to keep you and attract more," said Salinas Mayor Dennis Donohue. "You have to pay well to attract the type of officers with the standards we have."

 

Officials from both police unions could not be reached late Friday afternoon. The raises will be built into the city's general fund.

 

"It's a stretch, but we can make it," City Manager Dave Mora said of the costs. "But we have an excellent police force and have to remain competitive."

 

The terms of both unions' existing MOUs were good through the end of June, but competition from nearby agencies helped drive the early agreements. A city staff report cited hefty pay raises of more than 15 percent given last fall by the city of Monterey to its police force as part of the motivation.

 

The city staff report notes it will take at least 12 months - or two of the scheduled raises - before Salinas police salaries compare with those of Monterey. The report also says the raises are necessary to both retain and recruit qualified personnel.

 

Salinas' police force today has about 35 management personnel and 152 officers, with about 25 additional vacant positions, according to the city.

 

Mora said several of the vacancies could soon be filled by officers now in training and prospective officers undergoing background checks.

 

Donohue said the police force plays a vital role in city safety. "We're talking about community safety," he said. "A strong law enforcement capability is a part of that," he said.

 

 

 

BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

 

 

Copyright ă POLICEPAY.NET, Inc. 2007 All Rights Reserved

 

 

The POLICEPAY Journal

Published by:

POLICEPAY.NET, Inc.

219 West Boyd St, Suite 205

Norman, OK 73069

(405) 701-8616

www.policepay.net