The POLICEPAY Journal®

Thursday, February 8, 2007

www.policepayjournal.net  

Matt Barnard, Editor   matt@policepay.net    (405) 701-8616  

POLICEPAY.NET NEGOTIATION TRAINING                     

                    JULY 26-27            -      Santa Fe, NM        (click here for information)

NEW YORK CITY

City sues to kick-start police contract negotiations

NEWARK, OH

Police union ratifies contract

PARKERSBURG, WV

Police: Fix The System

SOMERSET COUNTY, MD

Deputies push for better pay

POLICEPAY.NET

HIRE POLICEPAY TO NEGOTIATE YOUR NEXT CONTRACT

                                             BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

 

City sues to kick-start police contract negotiations

State arbitration board dragging its heels, Bloomberg complains

From the Staten Island Advance, February 03, 2007

In the latest move over stalled contract talks between the city and its largest police union, the Bloomberg administration announced yesterday it is suing the state board charged with arbitrating the contract.

Fed up with what he called foot-dragging by the state Public Employment Relations Board, Mayor Michael Bloomberg says he wants a judge to force the board to appoint an arbitration panel -- over objections from the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association.

The city filed for arbitration in July, but the procedure stalled while PERB was naming the three-member board.

Under PERB rules, each side chooses a person from a list of nine names. Then an impartial chairperson is chosen from the list through a process of elimination, in which both sides take turns striking names.

PBA president Patrick Lynch objected to two of the names, contending they were biased because they had ruled unfavorably toward the PBA in past arbitration proceedings.

The Bloomberg administration's suit invokes PERB rules that say if one side refuses to strike names, then all names are acceptable. Under those rules, PERB must appoint a chair, the city argues.

The suit was filed in state Supreme Court, Albany, where PERB is based. A hearing is scheduled for Feb. 16.

The city has made fair offers to the PBA, one of which would give police officers the same raise that firefighters received while raising the starting salary to $38,000, Bloomberg said in a statement. What's inexplicable is how PERB has dragged its feet and slowed the arbitration process to a halt instead of appointing a panel to hear the case.

In response, PBA officials called the lawsuit a desperate attempt by the city to stack the deck against police officers by trying to name a biased arbitrator. The union said it has acted in the best interests of its officers and has complied with every directive issued by PERB in the current dispute.

 

Police union ratifies contract
Council OK needed
From the

NEWARK, OHIO — Federation of Police Local 127 approved a tentative three-year contract with the city of Newark in a vote Wednesday night.

After a presentation by union leadership, the members supported the proposed contract by a vote of 44-21. There were 76 members eligible to vote. FOP President Darrin Logan said he could not discuss details of the agreement until City Council takes action.

City Council’s Finance and Personnel committees will consider the contract at a special meeting 5 p.m. Thursday at the Newark Municipal Building. The full council will then consider the contract in a special meeting 5:15 p.m. Monday.

The cost of the contract could have a major impact on the city’s 2007 budget, which council just approved Monday night. The city administration and union have been negotiating the agreement since late 2006.

“We just need to know the exact impact because the budget is fragile,” said councilman David Rhodes, R-at large. “We want to make sure the city hasn’t been negotiated into harm’s way.”

The salary increase and benefits package in the FOP contract could influence city negotiations with the International Association of Fire Fighters Local 109 and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Local 2963. All three contracts expired Dec. 31, 2006, so the new contracts will be retroactive to Jan. 1.

“We got the best contract we could under the circumstances (of the city’s finances),” Mayor Bruce Bain said. “The FOP understood and we understood what the city went through last year.”

The city made severe budget cuts and laid off 14 employees in 2006 to balance the city budget. The economic picture improved this year, and city officials and City Council approved a budget with much less dramatic actions.

In late October, before the start of negotiations with the unions, Bain said, “We need one year of help from the unions. What we have to do is work with the unions and get the unions to trust in what we're saying. The days of 3-4-5 percent yearly raises are over. It’s unreasonable to have a large increase because we just had a layoff.”

In 2004, the police union and city agreed to a three-year contract including salary increases of 3 percent the first two years and 3.5 percent in the third year. The contract’s estimated cost was $15.2 million, including $10.5 million for salaries, $1.2 million estimated for overtime, as well as pension, pension pickup and Medicare costs.

The Newark Board of Health and AFCSME Local 2963 recently agreed to a three-year contract, retroactive to Jan. 1, providing salary increases of 3 percent the first year, 2 percent the second year, and 2.5 percent in the final year. The health department contract covers about 25 employees.

Newark Health Commissioner Judith Carr said the previous three-year contract included 1.5 percent raises in each year.

 

Police: Fix The System

From, WTAP, February 4, 2007

The head of Parkersburg's Fraternal Order of Police lodge disputes concerns that a proposed pay adjustment for police and fire department members amounts to a pay raise. In fact, he says most of the burden for the plan would actually be on uniformed officers themselves.

"The way it's paid now, we would get time and a half on a holiday, and we're going to drop to straight time on a holiday when we're off, so we're kicking off an additional five hours for every holiday when we're working," says Kevin Hornbeck, a police officer and President of F.O.P. Lodge #79. "So the officers are kicking in a majority of this money. So the officers are kicking in a majority of this money. Yes, the city's going to have to fund some of it, but I believe the majority of it is going to be funded by the officers themselves."

Hornbeck says that when he became a police officer in the 1990's, hundreds of people signed up to take the officer's exam. He says now, that number has fallen to 35, in part because other departments have better pay scales.

"The sheriff's department has a better pay system than we do," Hornbeck says. "Vienna Police Department has a better pay system than we do. And the Public Debt security guards make more money than an officer does at our department."

And police are still upset with city council, for approving a budget two years ago granting pay raises for civilian city workers, while cutting overtime and other benefits for uniformed workers.

"There are disparities in our pay system that need worked out, so we can be equal," Hornbeck says.

Hornbeck believes, however, the newer members of city council are more supportive of the pay needs of police and fire department members.

 

Deputies push for better pay

PRINCESS ANNE -- Somerset County Sheriff's Office employees are hoping to convince County Commissioners that offering better pay and retirement benefits will result in a better agency and one that is competitive with neighboring counties.

The current pay scale for deputies in Somerset County makes it difficult to recruit staff, Sheriff Robert Jones told the Somerset County Commissioners recently.

Somerset deputies such as Jennifer Hall said they want to stay in Somerset County, but the lower salaries are forcing them to look elsewhere. Hall, who is paying off college loans, said she can't afford to buy a house with her current pay.

"Our department merits a raise and retirements," she told commissioners.

Deputies in Somerset County start out at $32,662 compared to $38,900 in Worcester and $41,328 in Wicomico, according to the Maryland Sheriff's Association.

The top salary range in Somerset is $46,991 to $75,123 for a captain, while a captain in Worcester can make $84,841, and a major (a rank that is being phased out) in Wicomico can earn $66,729 to $94,926.

Even within Somerset County, police officers can earn more at the Princess Anne Police Department, University of Maryland Eastern Shore and Maryland State Police.

Aside from lower salaries, employees also must wait 30 years before they can retire, and Jones would like to change it to 25 which is offered in Wicomico County and other agencies, including the Princess Anne Police Department. Offering retirement five years earlier makes sense because most police officers can't handle the physical side of the job past a certain age.

"It's a young man's job," Jones said.

The sheriff also wants his department to enroll in the state's Law Enforcement Officers Pension System, which was started in 1990 for Maryland Natural Resources Police but has since expanded to include other state and local agencies. A representative from LEOPS was slated to visit the county last week to explain more about the program, including how much it will cost, Jones said.

If the county commissioners agree to participate, it will be figured into the fiscal 2008 budget which takes effect July 1. While the county's financial contribution to LEOPS would likely be "substantial," offering a better pension plan and earlier retirement will help keep the department competitive, Jones said.

It will also help retain employees like Sgt. Paul Williams who said he has been in the department since 1995 and would like to stay there, despite making $15,000 to $20,000 less than his counterparts at other agencies. Williams said he owns a house in the county and has two sons attending Washington High School.

"What goes on in this county means a lot to me," he said.

 

 

CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS

 

POLICEPAY provides complete contract negotiations for your bargaining unit.  We will:

 

  • Do all of the research work – wage survey, costing analysis, financial ability-to-pay
  • Train your executive board how to lobby and politic (at your place)
  • Meet with the key decision makers in your city – Chief, Mayor, Administrator
  • Provide all preparation for contract negotiations
  • Serve as your lead negotiator

 

Our fee will be a fixed amount that is agreed to up front.  The fee will include all costs, even travel and hotels.  There will be no surprises.  We offer options with no up front payment.  You can make equal monthly payments.  If your contract is 36 months, you will make 36 monthly payments.

 

During the term of the contract, we will:

 

  • Update your wage survey whenever there is a change
  • Update ability-to-pay reports annually
  • Provide monthly reports on major revenue (if data is available)
  • Meet with you annually to review strategies

 

If we are not able to reach an agreement with your city, we will provide arbitration services at no additional cost.  We intend to get an agreement.

 

Our approach to contract negotiations is different than what you are probably used to.  We engage in non-confrontational negotiations that rely on developing relationships.  However, we do not use so called “win-win” negotiation.  It’s a loser for you.  There will be no unfair labor practice complaints filed by us or lawsuits and grievances.  If that is what you are wanting you need to call the usual knucklehead lawyers that have been screwing up police negotiations for years.  Intimidation and blustering are not in our arsenal.

 

If you prefer to negotiate yourself we can provide any of the services listed above, with the same payment plans, only at lower rate.  If this is the way you want to go, you need to attend one of our negotiation seminars.  The upcoming seminars are listed on our website.

 

For more information, give us a call at (405) 234-2235, or contact Matt Barnard on his cell phone at (405) 413-6517. You may also email Matt at matt@policepay.net.

 

 

POLICEPAY.NET

 

Your Ultimate Solution For Contract Negotiations

 

www.policepay.net

 

 

 

BACK ISSUES OF THE JOURNAL

 

 

Copyright ã POLICEPAY.NET, Inc. 2007 All Rights Reserved

 

 

The POLICEPAY Journal

Published by:

POLICEPAY.NET, Inc.

219 West Boyd St, Suite 205

Norman, OK 73069

(405) 701-8616

www.policepay.net